Skip to content
AP U.S. History · Period 2: 1607-1754

Self governance

Self governance appears in 7 reviewed AP U.S. History questions and sits in Period 2: 1607-1754. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

The colonial practice of governing local affairs through elected representative bodies — Virginia's House of Burgesses from 1619, the compact signed aboard the Mayflower in 1620, New England town meetings, and every colony's assembly. Its core weapon was the power of the purse over taxes and officials' salaries.

Why it matters

Distance, weak enforcement, and Britain's need for colonial cooperation let these bodies accumulate real power for over a century. That habit of self-rule, not any single tax, is the long fuse that Period 3 lights.

How the exam tests it

It is usually tested through salutary neglect: a passage on failed imperial administration, then a question about long-term consequences, answered by assemblies grown accustomed to autonomy and resentful of later regulation. Stems often prompt continuity-and-change reasoning across Periods 2 and 3.

Don’t confuse it with

Democracy. Voting was restricted to property-holding white men, governors were appointed by the Crown or proprietors, and assemblies justified themselves by claiming the rights of Englishmen rather than by any theory of popular sovereignty.

Self governance in real questions

Example 1Medium
The Board of Trade, established by the English Crown in 1696 to oversee colonial administration and commerce, attempted to rationalize the relationship between Britain and its colonies. It sought to harmonize colonial laws with English law, reduce smuggling, enforce the Navigation Acts, and review colonial legislative acts. Yet enforcement remained inconsistent, custom houses were understaffed and corrupt, and colonial assemblies resisted reforms that threatened their legislative autonomy. The result was 'salutary neglect'—a system in which the colonies enjoyed substantial autonomy in practice, even if not in theory. The policy of 'salutary neglect' most directly contributed to which of the following long-term colonial developments?
  1. AThe complete economic independence of the colonies from Britain, which rendered the Navigation Acts irrelevant and freed colonial merchants from any reliance on British markets.
  2. BThe British Crown's deliberate policy of nurturing colonial assemblies as self-governing bodies, intended from the outset to prepare the colonies for eventual statehood.
  3. CThe colonists' deepening loyalty to British parliamentary authority, which they experienced as a consistently protective and beneficial force guiding colonial life.
  4. DThe growth of strong, self-governing colonial assemblies accustomed to legislative autonomy, which made later British attempts at stricter regulation and taxation deeply resented.Correct

Why D is right

Decades of salutary neglect allowed colonial assemblies to grow in power, confidence, and legislative autonomy; when Britain attempted to tighten regulation after the Seven Years' War (Stamp Act, Townshend Acts), colonists experienced it as a violation of long-established custom and their 'rights as Englishmen'—making the shift in British policy after 1763 particularly explosive.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because colonial merchants were integrated into the Atlantic economy and depended on British markets and credit; the Navigation Acts were widely evaded rather than irrelevant, and colonial economic independence was partial, not complete.
B
Incorrect because salutary neglect was not a deliberate plan to prepare for statehood; it was the unintended result of administrative weakness, corruption, and transatlantic distance, not a Crown strategy aimed at colonial self-government.
C
Incorrect because salutary neglect produced the opposite effect: colonists developed habits of self-governance that made later parliamentary assertion feel like tyranny, so when Britain tried to enforce authority they resisted rather than deferring out of loyalty.
Example 2Medium
"The American Anti-Imperialist League, founded 1898: Prominent members included Mark Twain, Andrew Carnegie, Jane Addams, and Samuel Gompers. The League opposed American annexation of the Philippines, arguing that governing a distant people without their consent violated American democratic principles and the Declaration of Independence." — Modern description of the Anti-Imperialist League The Anti-Imperialist League's argument most directly challenged which aspect of the case for American imperialism?
  1. AThe humanitarian argument that American rule would benefit Filipino peoples by ending Spanish misrule, since anti-imperialists believed American rule would be equally exploitative
  2. BThe economic argument that colonies would provide new markets for American manufactured goods, which anti-imperialists argued was economically incorrect because colonies were expensive to maintain
  3. CThe military argument that Pacific island possessions would strengthen American naval power, which anti-imperialists argued was strategically unnecessary since the United States had sufficient domestic security
  4. DThe claim that American democratic values were compatible with governing distant peoples without their consent, which anti-imperialists argued was a fundamental contradiction of American founding principlesCorrect

Why D is right

The Anti-Imperialist League's central argument was a principled one about self-governance and democratic consent: that the Declaration of Independence's principles — that governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed — were fundamentally incompatible with governing Filipinos as colonial subjects without their agreement. Mark Twain's savage anti-imperialist essays (including 'The War Prayer') made this point most eloquently: America could not be both a democracy at home and an empire abroad without betraying its own founding values. This argument also often carried, unfortunately, a racist undercurrent arguing that non-white peoples were ungovernable and would corrupt American democracy.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because while some anti-imperialists did raise humanitarian concerns about American colonial rule, the primary argument identified in the passage — and historically most characteristic of the League — was the democratic principles argument about governing without consent.
B
Incorrect because while anti-imperialists did make economic arguments, the primary and most distinctive argument of the Anti-Imperialist League was the democratic-principles argument about consent and self-governance, not primarily an economic one.
C
Incorrect because the anti-imperialists' challenge was primarily moral and principled rather than strategic; they were arguing against imperialism as a violation of American values, not primarily making strategic calculations about naval necessity.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Period 2: 1607-1754.