8 topics. Each one opens with its key idea, then the detail you need to use it.
1. The Chesapeake: tobacco, servants, and the crisis of 1676
Key idea: Bacon's Rebellion is tested as a cause: class conflict among whites pushed Virginia planters toward permanent racial slavery.
Virginia survived because John Rolfe's sweeter West Indian tobacco found a European market by the late 1610s. Tobacco then dictated the colony's shape. The headright system granted fifty acres to anyone who paid a person's Atlantic passage, so wealthy planters imported indentured servants and collected land for each body. Servants signed away four to seven years for passage, food, and a promised freedom package. Many died first; disease and overwork killed enormous numbers before their terms ended.
That system built a class problem. Survivors emerged landless just as tobacco prices sagged and the best tidewater soil was taken, so they pushed onto the frontier and collided with Native nations. Governor William Berkeley refused to launch a general war, partly to protect his own fur trade and allied tribes. In 1676 Nathaniel Bacon, a well-connected newcomer, raised an unauthorized force, massacred friendly Natives including the Occaneechee and Pamunkey, then turned on the capital and burned Jamestown in September. His force mixed poor whites, indentured servants, and enslaved Africans, and the last holdouts surrendered only after Bacon died of dysentery.
The rebellion terrified the planter elite, but not into reform. Berkeley hanged the leaders and Virginia's gentry kept control. What changed was labor strategy: planters accelerated the shift toward enslaved Africans, who served for life, could never claim land, and could be legally barred from arms and courts. Race then became the wedge that kept poor whites from allying with the enslaved again.
2. New England: covenant, town, and the limits of dissent
Key idea: New England's fights over Williams, Hutchinson, and Salem are all about one thing: a covenant community that treated private religious deviation as a public threat.
Two migrations founded New England. The Plymouth colonists of 1620 were Separatists who had cut ties with the Church of England. Blown north of their Virginia Company grant, they had no legal authority to govern, so forty-one men signed the Mayflower Compact, converting a religious covenant into a civil one. The Massachusetts Bay migration of 1630 was larger and richer. Its Puritans wanted to purify the Church of England from within and build a visible model of a godly society; roughly twenty thousand followed in the Great Migration of the 1630s.
The mechanism to understand is covenant theology. The community, not just the individual, stood in an agreement with God, so tolerating error invited collective punishment. That is why dissent was a public safety issue. The General Court ordered Roger Williams banished in October 1635 for arguing that civil magistrates had no authority over religious duties and that royal charters could not grant land the Native peoples actually owned. He fled in January 1636 and founded Providence that year. Anne Hutchinson was tried and sentenced to banishment in November 1637 for teaching that grace came through direct experience of the Spirit rather than through ministerial guidance, a position her judges called antinomian. Her church excommunicated her in March 1638 and she left the colony.
The pressure kept building. The Halfway Covenant of 1662 loosened membership rules because too few of the second generation could testify to conversion. After King Philip's War, the loss of the charter in 1684, and the Dominion years, the Salem accusations of 1692 exploded through a community under strain, hanging nineteen people and pressing one man to death.
3. The Middle Colonies: New York, Pennsylvania, and toleration as policy
Key idea: Quaker belief in the Inner Light produced Pennsylvania's religious toleration and fair land dealing, and toleration then attracted the migration that made the Middle Colonies the most diverse region.
The Middle Colonies were diverse before the English got there. New Netherland was a Dutch trading operation that recruited settlers from across Europe, ran huge patroonship estates along the Hudson, and tolerated multiple faiths for commercial reasons. When England seized it in 1664 and renamed it New York for the Duke of York, that mixed population stayed, along with the manor estates and their long-running tenant grievances.
Pennsylvania was a deliberate experiment. Charles II granted the land to William Penn in 1681 to settle a debt owed to Penn's father, and Penn built a Quaker colony. Quaker theology centers on the Inner Light: God's spirit speaks directly to every person, which makes forced worship both useless and offensive. Quakers had been jailed and beaten in England and hanged in Massachusetts, so toleration was a lesson learned firsthand. Penn's Frame of Government in 1682 guaranteed an annual assembly of freemen and protected anyone who acknowledged one God from being punished for conscience.
Penn also bought land from the Lenape through negotiated purchases rather than seizing it, which bought decades of relative peace. That policy did not survive him; his sons ran the fraudulent Walking Purchase in 1737. Meanwhile toleration worked as advertising. German and Scots-Irish migrants poured in, Philadelphia grew into a major port, and the wheat trade made the region the breadbasket of British North America.
4. South Carolina: the Caribbean model on the mainland
Key idea: South Carolina's Black majority and rice economy made resistance likely and repression severe; Stono produced harsher slave codes, not reconsideration.
South Carolina, settled from 1670, was founded largely by planters from Barbados, and they brought a finished system with them: large estates, harsh slave law, and the assumption that enslaved labor was the point. Rice became the staple by the 1690s, and West Africans from rice-growing regions supplied both the labor and, in many cases, the agricultural knowledge. Indigo later added a second export crop.
The demographics were unlike anywhere else on the mainland. By roughly 1708 South Carolina had a Black majority, and in the low country rice parishes enslaved people outnumbered whites several times over. Rice cultivation used a task system: an enslaved worker who finished an assigned task had the remainder of the day, which allowed slightly more autonomy than tobacco's gang labor but under lethal working conditions in the malarial swamps. Carolina also ran the largest mainland trade in enslaved Native people, arming allies to raid Spanish mission towns in Florida.
A Black majority meant constant fear of revolt, and in 1739 the fear proved sound. About twenty enslaved men near the Stono River seized weapons on a Sunday morning while enslavers were at church, beat drums, called for liberty, and marched toward Spanish Florida, which had promised freedom to fugitives. Roughly twenty colonists died before the militia crushed them. The colonial response was the Negro Act of 1740: bans on assembly, on earning money, on learning to write, and tighter movement controls.
5. Slavery written into law, and the first voices against it
Key idea: Slavery in the English colonies was assembled statute by statute for planter benefit, and pre-1754 opposition was a minority religious argument, not an organized movement.
The Atlantic slave trade moved roughly twelve and a half million people from Africa across the ocean between the sixteenth and nineteenth centuries. Only a small share, under five percent, went directly to mainland North America; most went to Brazil and the Caribbean. The Middle Passage killed around fifteen percent in transit. English colonies entered the trade heavily after 1672, when the Royal African Company held a monopoly, and volume rose again once that monopoly ended in 1698 and independent traders flooded in.
Law did the rest. Virginia's 1662 statute made enslaved status pass through the mother, so a planter's children by enslaved women increased his property. The 1667 statute declared baptism no barrier to enslavement, closing the loophole that Christianity implied freedom. Early codes used religion as a stand-in for race by defining anyone not Christian in their native country as enslaveable. As Christian Africans arrived, the language shifted to explicit racial categories. Virginia's comprehensive 1705 code classified enslaved people as real estate and banned free Black colonists from holding office or testifying against whites.
Antislavery in this period is real but small and mostly religious. Four Quakers in Germantown, Pennsylvania signed a petition in 1688 arguing that buying stolen human beings violated the command to treat others as you would be treated; their meeting shelved it. Samuel Sewall, a Boston judge who had sat at Salem, published The Selling of Joseph in 1700 arguing all people descend from one ancestor. Benjamin Lay attacked slaveholding Quakers in 1737. Georgia's trustees banned slavery in 1735 and then repealed the ban in 1750, effective in 1751, under planter pressure, with Whitefield among those urging repeal.
6. Indigenous resistance and indigenous strategy
Key idea: Native resistance succeeded through coordination, timing, and local knowledge, and even accommodation was a deliberate strategy rather than passivity.
By the 1670s Native nations east and west faced the same squeeze: expanding settlement, demands for labor and tribute, and attacks on their religious life. Two responses in the same decade define the period. In New England, the Wampanoag sachem Metacom, called King Philip by the English, watched Plymouth's courts extend jurisdiction over his people and settlers take Wampanoag land. In 1675 he assembled a coalition that included Nipmuc fighters and other allies, and they attacked dozens of towns. The Narragansett were not in that original coalition. Colonial forces attacked their fortified winter camp in the Great Swamp Fight of December 1675, and the survivors fought the English in 1676. Proportionally the war was among the deadliest in American history. Metacom was killed in 1676, colonists sold captives into Caribbean slavery, and independent Native power in southern New England was broken.
In New Mexico in 1680, Spanish Franciscans were destroying kivas and punishing traditional ceremonies while the encomienda extracted labor. Popé, a Tewa religious leader from Ohkay Owingeh (San Juan Pueblo), organized the rising from Taos, where he had taken refuge after Spanish authorities flogged him for practicing Pueblo religion. He coordinated roughly seventeen thousand Pueblo people across a vast area. Runners carried knotted cords, each knot marking a day until the rising. When Spanish officials caught two messengers, Popé moved the date up rather than abandon the plan. About four hundred Spanish colonists died, including twenty-one of the province's Franciscan missionaries, and Spain was driven out for twelve years. Spain reconquered the region in 1692 but afterward eased religious persecution and abandoned the encomienda there.
Not all agency looked like war. The Haudenosaunee used the Covenant Chain alliance with New York to trade and negotiate from strength, and many communities converted or relocated as calculated survival strategies.
7. Mercantilism, British policy, and the habit of self-rule
Key idea: Britain's mercantilist rules were strict on paper and loosely enforced, and that gap let colonial assemblies build a working tradition of self-government.
Mercantilism assumed a fixed quantity of world wealth, so a colony existed to enrich the parent country: supply raw materials, buy finished goods, and avoid trading with rivals. Parliament wrote that theory into the Navigation Acts beginning in 1651. Colonial goods had to travel in English or colonial ships. Enumerated commodities, including tobacco, sugar, and indigo, could be sold only within the empire, and European goods bound for the colonies had to pass through England first. Violations went to admiralty courts, which had no juries and therefore no sympathetic local neighbors on the panel.
Enforcement was another matter. Smuggling was routine, customs officials were few and bribable, and the arrangement suited many colonists anyway, since tobacco and shipbuilding enjoyed protected markets. When London did tighten, colonists pushed back hard. The Dominion of New England, imposed in 1686, dissolved assemblies and voided land titles under Governor Edmund Andros; Bostonians jailed him in 1689 once news of the Glorious Revolution arrived, and Leisler's Rebellion did something similar in New York.
Meanwhile assemblies accumulated real power. The House of Burgesses had met since 1619, and colonial legislatures used the power of the purse, including control of governors' salaries, to force concessions. John Locke supplied the vocabulary: his Two Treatises of Government, published in 1689, grounded government in consent and natural rights to life, liberty, and property, and defended resistance to rulers who violated them. Locke had also helped draft Carolina's aristocratic constitutions, a contradiction worth remembering.
8. The Great Awakening and the Enlightenment: two challenges to authority
Key idea: Whitefield's itinerant, emotional revivalism democratized spiritual authority and split denominations, while Enlightenment reason gave educated colonists a second way to question established authority; both worked slowly.
By the 1720s many colonial churches felt cold and formal, and Enlightenment rationalism was pulling educated colonists toward a distant, orderly God. The revivals ran the opposite way. Jonathan Edwards, preaching at Northampton, insisted that salvation was an overwhelming, felt encounter with God, and his 1741 sermon on sinners in the hands of an angry God used vivid imagery to force listeners to confront damnation personally. George Whitefield, an English itinerant with an extraordinary voice, arrived in 1739 and toured the colonies through 1741, drawing crowds in the thousands outdoors from Georgia to New England.
The method mattered as much as the message. Whitefield ignored parish boundaries, preached in fields and streets, advertised in newspapers, and printed his sermons, creating something close to a shared intercolonial event. Ordinary listeners were told that a conversion experience, not education or social rank, marked a true Christian. Congregants began judging whether their own settled ministers were converted, which is a direct attack on credentialed authority.
The consequences were institutional and cultural. Churches split into New Lights, who embraced revival, and Old Lights, who condemned the emotionalism. Baptist and Presbyterian numbers surged, denominational competition intensified, and revivalists founded colleges including Princeton and Dartmouth. Total religious participation rose rather than fell. The political effect was indirect and slow: a population practiced at questioning established authority in church was more receptive to questioning it elsewhere decades later.
The Enlightenment ran alongside the revivals as the other new current, and the exam pairs them. It held that reason and observation could uncover natural law in the physical and political world. Benjamin Franklin is the model colonial case: electrical experiments, a self-improvement club and a subscription library in Philadelphia, and a deist's God who set the universe running by fixed laws and did not intervene. That same climate made Locke's argument from natural rights and consent persuasive to educated colonists. Revival made spiritual authority personal; the Enlightenment made political authority something you could reason about.