"Our factory in Canton operates under the most peculiar restrictions. We must conduct all business through the licensed Cohong merchants; we may not learn the Chinese language; we may not enter the city of Canton itself; our women may not accompany us to China; and we may trade only in the season of the monsoon. The Chinese authorities regard us as tribute bearers rather than equal trading partners, yet we submit to these conditions because the tea and silk we bring home to Britain make fortunes large enough to justify any indignity. The emperor's regulations are humiliating but profitable."
—British East India Company official, Canton, 1790
The sentiments expressed most directly reflect which of the following?
- AThe Canton System, through which Qing China strictly regulated and limited European commercial access while maintaining Chinese sovereignty over trade termsCorrect
- BThe British East India Company's preference for indirect trade through Chinese intermediaries, which the Company found more efficient than direct negotiation with Qing officials
- CEuropean commercial interests in China were unprofitable before the Opium Wars because Chinese restrictions prevented British merchants from accessing lucrative markets
- DThe tributary system's successful integration of European trading powers into the Chinese world order on equal terms with Asian neighbors
Why A is right
The passage describes all the key features of the Canton System: trade restricted to Canton, mandatory use of Cohong intermediaries, language restrictions, residency restrictions, and seasonal trade—all imposed by Chinese authorities who viewed Europeans as tribute bearers, not equals. The British official accepts these humiliating conditions because trade is profitable enough, illustrating how China maintained sovereignty over trade terms while Europeans accepted them for commercial gain.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- The British official clearly resents the restrictions ('humiliating,' 'peculiar,' 'submit to these conditions'), indicating these were imposed requirements rather than preferred arrangements; the Company did not choose Cohong intermediaries voluntarily.
- C
- The official states trade was profitable enough to 'justify any indignity' and 'make fortunes large enough'; British trade in Canton was highly profitable precisely because of tea and silk demand.
- D
- The passage explicitly notes the Chinese regard Europeans 'as tribute bearers rather than equal trading partners'—the opposite of integration on equal terms; the tributary system deliberately subordinated foreign traders.