A Byzantine chronicler, Account of the Fall of Constantinople (1453): 'The Sultan entered the city in triumph, riding a white horse. He ordered that the great church of Hagia Sophia be converted at once into a mosque. The Christian empire, which had stood for over a thousand years, was extinguished in a single afternoon. The Sultan wept when he saw the ruined palaces, saying: what city have we given over to plunder and destruction?'
A historian could best use this source to support which argument?
- AOttoman rulers were indifferent to the architectural and cultural heritage of the cities they conquered
- BThe fall of Constantinople in 1453 marked the definitive end of the Western Roman Empire's political legacy in Europe
- CThe Ottoman conquest combined military triumph with ambivalence toward the vanquished Byzantine civilizationCorrect
- DByzantine resistance successfully preserved most Christian institutions within the Ottoman Empire
Why C is right
The source shows Mehmed II celebrating victory while expressing grief at the city's destruction — a nuanced portrayal of Ottoman attitudes. This supports an argument about Ottoman rulers' complex relationship with conquered cultures, simultaneously transforming institutions (Hagia Sophia) while lamenting cultural loss.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The Sultan's reported weeping over the ruined palaces directly contradicts indifference to cultural heritage.
- B
- The Western Roman Empire had already fallen in 476 CE; Constantinople was the Eastern Roman Empire's capital, so its fall does not mark the end of a Western legacy.
- D
- While the Ottoman Empire did tolerate some Christian practices, the source emphasizes the conversion of Hagia Sophia, not the preservation of Byzantine Christian institutions.
A Venetian diplomat's account (c. 1430): 'The Ottoman Sultan Murad II has taken Thessaloniki from us and now presses against Constantinople itself. His janissaries are the finest soldiers in the world: Christian boys taken as children and raised Muslim, trained from youth as warriors without family or land. They are loyal only to the Sultan who took them, for they have nothing else. It is a terrible system and a very effective one.'
The sentiments expressed most directly reflect which of the following?
- AThe Venetian diplomat's admiration for the Ottoman military system, which Venice subsequently copied to build its own standing professional army drawn from converted captives
- BThe gradual replacement of the janissary corps by European-trained soldiers after the Ottomans adopted Renaissance-era military technology and tactics from their Italian rivals
- CThe Ottoman Empire's policy of forcibly converting entire Christian populations to Islam through military coercion across all of its conquered territories in the Balkans
- DThe devshirme system's creation of an elite force whose loyalty derived from the recruits' removal from all competing social ties and total dependence on the SultanCorrect
Why D is right
The Venetian's description precisely captures the devshirme system's political logic: by taking boys from their families, converting them, and raising them with no ties except to the Sultan, the Ottomans created soldiers whose loyalty was absolute because they had no competing kinship, land, or community obligations. The diplomat's observation ('loyal only to the Sultan for they have nothing else') identifies the deliberate structural basis of janissary loyalty.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- The diplomat expresses horrified admiration, not a plan to copy the system; Venice maintained a very different military based on hired mercenaries and civic militia, never a converted-captive standing army.
- B
- The janissary corps remained the Ottoman army's elite infantry for centuries after this account; it was not replaced by European-trained soldiers in the 15th century.
- C
- The devshirme was a selective levy of Christian boys, not a universal forced conversion; most Balkan Christian communities retained their religion under Ottoman rule.
"The Ottoman devshirme system recruited Christian boys from Balkan villages, converted them to Islam, and trained them for elite military or administrative service. The most promising became Janissaries -- the sultan's elite infantry corps -- or rose to positions as grand viziers and provincial governors. This system provided the Ottoman state with a loyal, meritocratic administrative and military elite whose power derived entirely from the sultan, rather than from hereditary aristocratic families. Parents sometimes sought to have their sons recruited, seeing devshirme as a path to power and prosperity." -- Modern historian's assessment.
The devshirme system, as described in the passage, served primarily to
- Apromote religious tolerance by permitting recruited Christian boys to retain their original faith while holding office in the Ottoman state
- Bstrengthen the sultan's central authority through a loyal elite dependent on imperial patronage rather than hereditary privilegeCorrect
- Cencourage broad democratic participation by allowing ordinary Ottoman subjects to elect officials and share in governing the empire
- Dweaken the Ottoman military over time by replacing seasoned hereditary cavalry with poorly trained foreign conscripts
Why B is right
The passage explicitly states that the devshirme created an elite 'whose power derived entirely from the sultan, rather than from hereditary aristocratic families.' This system strengthened central authority by ensuring that the most powerful military and administrative officials owed their positions to the sultan personally, preventing the emergence of independent hereditary power bases.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the passage states that recruited boys were converted to Islam, so they did not retain their original Christian faith while serving.
- C
- Incorrect because the devshirme was a system of selective recruitment and elite formation; it produced a meritocratic administrative class, not democratic participation or elected office.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage describes the devshirme producing an 'elite infantry corps' and high-ranking officials, indicating that it strengthened rather than weakened military capability.