Skip to content
AP World History: Modern · Consequences of Industrialization

Selective borrowing

Selective borrowing appears in 5 reviewed AP World History: Modern questions and sits in Consequences of Industrialization. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

A way of modernizing that imports foreign technology, military methods, and government institutions, while protecting the home society's core sources of legitimacy and identity: its religion, its ruling dynasty, and its cultural tradition.

Why it matters

It is the pattern behind Meiji Japan and the Qing Self-Strengthening Movement of 1861-1895. The Chinese version was later summed up in Zhang Zhidong's 1898 formula: Chinese learning for essence, Western learning for use. Notice what selective borrowing does not have to protect. Meiji Japan kept the emperor sacred, but tore up the social order underneath him. It abolished the domains in 1871, ended the legal four-class system, cut off samurai stipends by 1876, and imposed universal conscription in 1873. Qing reformers did leave the social order in place. That is part of why Japan became an industrial great power, while China built arsenals and shipyards but never rebuilt the state.

How the exam tests it

Expect a memorial to the Qing court, or a statement by a Meiji official, listing new arsenals, dockyards, and students sent abroad. Then one line insists the ancestral or Confucian base stays untouched. The credited answer pairs foreign technology with preserved traditional authority. Distractors offer total rejection of the West, or dropping tradition entirely.

Don’t confuse it with

Westernization, which targets the culture itself. A selective borrower takes the rails, rifles, and legal codes, but walls off the emperor, the classics, and the state religion.

Selective borrowing in real questions

Example 1Harder
"The Confucian scholar examines the classics; the Buddhist monk prays; the Taoist hermit seeks the Way — but none of them has told us how to make a steel rail, how to build a telegraph line, or how to command a modern navy. China's weakness before the Western powers is not a spiritual failure but a technical one. We must send our best young men to study in America and Europe, learn their science and their engineering, then bring their knowledge home to strengthen China." —Memorial to the Qing court, attributed to a Self-Strengthening reformer, c. 1872 The excerpt best illustrates which of the following continuities in Chinese history?
  1. AThe ongoing tension between Confucian scholarly traditions and the demands of administrative modernization within the Chinese imperial bureaucracy
  2. BThe persistent debate among Chinese political elites over whether to fully engage with or deliberately disengage from the outside world
  3. CThe recurring pattern of Chinese reformers adopting foreign technology while preserving China's existing cultural and political systemCorrect
  4. DThe growing dominance of practical technical education over classical learning within the Qing imperial examination system

Why C is right

The Self-Strengthening Movement's formula 'Chinese learning for the fundamental principles, Western learning for practical application' (Zhongti Xiyong) represents a Chinese version of the selective borrowing pattern also seen in Meiji Japan. This specific approach — adopting foreign technology to strengthen the existing system without changing its cultural or political foundations — recurs throughout Chinese reform history, from the Self-Strengthening Movement to later debates about modernization while maintaining Chinese characteristics.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Although tension between classical and technical learning is present in the passage, the author's main argument is specifically about importing foreign technology to strengthen China, not about an internal Confucian-versus-modernization struggle inside the bureaucracy.
B
The author already favors engagement abroad for technical purposes, so the excerpt does not debate whether to engage; it argues how to benefit from engagement while preserving the Chinese essence, making this framing incorrect.
D
The imperial examination system remained dominated by classical Confucian learning throughout the Qing, and the Self-Strengthening Movement worked within that framework rather than displacing it, so this choice is factually incorrect.
Example 2Easier
"The Meiji government has wisely seen that in order to maintain the independence of our Empire, we must abandon the old ways. We have sent our young men to study in the universities of Europe and America. We have built arsenals, dockyards, and telegraph lines. We have adopted a constitution modeled upon that of Prussia. Yet in all these endeavours, we have not abandoned the spirit of our ancestors. The Emperor remains sacred and inviolable, and the loyalty of the subject to the sovereign remains the foundation of our national strength." — Japanese intellectual, 1890 The perspective expressed in this passage most closely aligns with which of the following approaches to modernization?
  1. ARevolutionary transformation that sought to entirely uproot inherited social hierarchies and political institutions in favor of imported Western models
  2. BSocialist modernization that prioritized state ownership of industry and the redistribution of land and wealth to the peasantry and urban workers
  3. CSelective adoption of Western technology and institutions while preserving core elements of traditional authority and identityCorrect
  4. DConservative resistance to all foreign influence in order to insulate indigenous cultural, religious, and political traditions from change

Why C is right

The passage explicitly describes Japan adopting Western technology, education, and constitutional structures while maintaining the emperor's sacred authority and traditional loyalty. This selective modernization was the hallmark of the Meiji approach, often summarized as 'Western technology, Eastern spirit.'
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the passage stresses that traditional elements such as imperial authority and the spirit of the ancestors were deliberately preserved, rather than uprooted in a total revolutionary break.
B
Incorrect because the passage describes a state-led modernization centered on imperial authority and Western-style institutions, not socialist principles of collective ownership or wealth redistribution.
D
Incorrect because the passage celebrates the extensive adoption of Western practices, including universities, arsenals, and a Prussian-modeled constitution, which contradicts a stance of resisting all foreign influence.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Consequences of Industrialization.