An environmental policy analyst evaluates a proposed carbon tax set at $50 per metric ton of CO2. If a coal-fired power plant emits 1.2 metric tons of CO2 per megawatt-hour (MWh) of electricity produced, and the plant produces 5,000 MWh per day, what would be the plant's daily carbon tax liability?
- A$60,000 per day
- B$600,000 per day
- C$3,000,000 per day
- D$300,000 per dayCorrect
Why D is right
Daily CO2 emissions = 1.2 metric tons CO2/MWh × 5,000 MWh/day = 6,000 metric tons CO2/day. Daily tax = 6,000 metric tons × $50/metric ton = $300,000/day. Over a year, this would be $109.5 million. A $50/ton carbon price is in the range considered meaningful for energy transition incentives, though economists argue prices of $100-200+/ton may be needed to achieve Paris Agreement targets. This type of calculation demonstrates why carbon pricing can significantly alter the economics of fossil fuel power generation relative to renewables.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. $60,000/day would result from: 5,000 MWh × $12/MWh, or from forgetting to multiply by 1.2 and using only 5,000 × $12. The full calculation requires multiplying emissions intensity × production × tax rate.
- B
- Incorrect. $600,000/day would result from using 12,000 metric tons of CO2 (doubling the correct 6,000), which could come from using 2.4 tons CO2/MWh instead of 1.2, or applying the tax to the number of MWh directly.
- C
- Incorrect. $3,000,000/day would result from using $100/ton (double the stated rate) or from calculating 6,000 × $500 instead of $50. The stated tax rate is $50/metric ton.