A researcher studying PTSD treatment compares veterans who chose to attend group therapy (n = 40) versus those who did not attend (n = 40) and finds that the therapy group has significantly lower PTSD symptoms. What is the primary reason the researcher CANNOT conclude that therapy reduced PTSD symptoms?
- APTSD symptoms are subjective and cannot be meaningfully measured with the standardized instruments researchers typically use
- BThe study lacks a placebo condition, so any improvement could be attributed to general attention rather than the therapy
- CThe sample size is too small to detect significant differences between groups
- DWithout random assignment, the groups may have differed at the start; those who chose therapy may be more motivatedCorrect
Why D is right
Without random assignment, this is a quasi-experimental study. Veterans who chose therapy may be more motivated to improve, less severely affected, or more socially supported — all of which could explain lower PTSD symptoms independent of therapy. Pre-existing group differences (self-selection confound) prevent causal conclusions.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because PTSD symptoms can be reliably measured using validated standardized scales (e.g., PCL-5); measurement validity is not the primary limitation here.
- B
- Incorrect because a placebo condition addresses expectancy effects; the more fundamental problem is that groups self-selected, creating pre-existing differences that confound the comparison.
- C
- Incorrect because n = 40 per group is a reasonable sample size for detecting moderate effects; the primary limitation is the absence of random assignment, not sample size.