- A
- Incorrect because an illusory correlation is a perceived relationship that does not actually exist in the data; here the survey found a real positive correlation, and the error lies in inferring which variable causes which.
- C
- Incorrect because punishment and aggression rise together, which makes this a positive correlation; variables that decrease together are also positively correlated, and in any case the flaw concerns causal direction, not the sign of the correlation.
- D
- Incorrect because nothing in the study suggests that only extreme families were sampled; the parents varied in how often they used punishment, and the error is drawing a one-way causal conclusion from correlational data.