Skip to content
AP Statistics · Exploring One-Variable Data and Collecting Data

Correlation causation

Correlation causation appears in 15 reviewed AP Statistics questions and sits in Exploring One-Variable Data and Collecting Data. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Correlation causation is tested

Example 1Medium
A researcher studying climate data finds that r = 0.88 between average summer temperature and annual wildfire area (in thousands of acres) across 30 regions. Which of the following would provide the strongest evidence that increased temperatures CAUSE increased wildfire area?
  1. AIncreasing the sample to 300 regions and showing the correlation is statistically significant.
  2. BFitting a regression model with r^2 > 0.90.
  3. CConducting a randomized experiment that randomly assigns temperatures to regions.Correct
  4. DFinding r = 0.99 instead of 0.88 in a follow-up study.

Why C is right

Causation can only be established through a randomized experiment where the explanatory variable (temperature) is randomly assigned. In practice, randomly assigning temperatures to regions is not feasible, but the principle stands: only random assignment of the treatment controls for confounding variables and allows causal inference. Observational studies (including correlations) can only show association.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because increasing sample size and achieving statistical significance means the observed association is unlikely to be due to chance, but it does not eliminate confounding or establish causation. Statistical significance ≠ causation.
B
Incorrect because r^2 > 0.90 is a measure of explanatory power in the regression model. A higher r^2 still cannot establish causation — it only means more variation in the response is explained by the predictor.
D
Incorrect because a stronger correlation (r = 0.99) still only shows stronger association, not causation. No value of r, no matter how close to 1, can establish causation from observational data.
Example 2Medium
A student computes the correlation between shoe size and IQ score for a sample of 200 adults. The student finds r = 0.72 and concludes that having larger feet causes people to have higher IQs. Which of the following identifies the flaw in this reasoning?
  1. ACorrelation does not imply causation; a lurking variable such as age or overall body size may explain both.Correct
  2. BA correlation of 0.72 is too weak to draw any conclusions about the relationship.
  3. CThe correlation should have been computed using Spearman's rank method for body measurements.
  4. DThe sample size of 200 is too small to compute a valid correlation.

Why A is right

Even a strong correlation does not establish causation. In this case, a lurking variable such as age (children have smaller feet and lower measured IQ) or overall body size could explain both variables simultaneously. The correlation captures a statistical association, not a causal mechanism.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because r = 0.72 is actually considered a moderately strong correlation. The problem is not the weakness of the correlation but the invalid causal inference.
C
Incorrect because Pearson correlation is appropriate for quantitative data. There is no requirement to use Spearman's rank correlation for physical measurements.
D
Incorrect because n = 200 is actually a reasonably large sample for computing correlation. Sample size affects the precision and significance of r, but 200 is sufficient.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Exploring One-Variable Data and Collecting Data.