Which of the following is an example of a study in which a cross-sectional design is more appropriate than a prospective cohort design?
- ATracking how smoking behavior changes over a person's lifetime
- BDetermining whether childhood nutrition affects adult height
- CEstimating the current prevalence of diabetes within a cityCorrect
- DStudying whether a new drug prevents cancer over 10 years
Why C is right
A cross-sectional study is ideal for estimating prevalence — the proportion of people with a condition at a specific point in time. Measuring current diabetes rates in a city requires only a single data collection at one time point, making a cross-sectional design efficient and appropriate. No follow-up or longitudinal tracking is needed.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. Tracking changes in smoking behavior over a lifetime requires longitudinal data collection over many years, not a single snapshot.
- B
- Incorrect. Studying the effect of childhood nutrition on adult height requires measuring nutrition in childhood and height in adulthood, which requires a longitudinal (prospective) design.
- D
- Incorrect. Studying cancer prevention over 10 years requires following participants over time, which is a prospective cohort or experimental design, not cross-sectional.