In a study on the effectiveness of a new ergonomic keyboard in reducing wrist pain, a researcher randomly assigns office workers to use the new keyboard or their standard keyboard for 8 weeks. At the end of the study, workers complete a self-report pain survey. Which aspect of this design could MOST limit the validity of the pain measurements?
- AThe random assignment to keyboard type.
- BDemand characteristics: participants who know they have the 'new' ergonomic keyboard may report less pain because they expect improvement.Correct
- CThe use of self-report rather than physiological pain measurement.
- DThe 8-week study duration.
Why B is right
Demand characteristics occur when participants' knowledge of the study's purpose or their treatment condition influences their responses. Workers who know they have the new 'ergonomic' keyboard may expect it to help and therefore report less pain than they truly experience, inflating the apparent effectiveness of the keyboard. Blinding (not telling workers which keyboard is 'ergonomic') would reduce this bias.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Random assignment is a strength of the design — it controls for confounding. It does not limit measurement validity.
- C
- While self-report has limitations, demand characteristics are a more specific and direct threat to validity in this context, because participants' expectations about the treatment directly influence their self-reports.
- D
- 8 weeks may or may not be long enough, but duration does not directly introduce measurement bias in the same specific way as demand characteristics.