A histogram of household incomes in a county is strongly right-skewed. The mean income is $72,000 and the median income is $55,000. A local politician claims that "the average household earns $72,000 per year." Why is this statement potentially misleading?
- AThe mean is always inaccurate for large data sets because rounding errors accumulate when many incomes are added together
- BThe politician should use the mode instead of the mean for income data
- CThe mean is pulled up by the high-income tail, so it overstates what a typical household earnsCorrect
- DHousehold income should be reported as a proportion, not a dollar amount
Why C is right
In a right-skewed distribution, the mean is pulled toward the tail by high-income earners, making it larger than the median. The median ($55,000) better represents the income of a typical household. Reporting the mean ($72,000) overstates what a typical household earns.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the mean is a mathematically precise calculation; it does not become inaccurate from accumulated rounding. The issue is that it is not representative of the typical value in skewed distributions.
- B
- Incorrect because the mode is rarely used as the primary measure of center for continuous data like income; the median is the appropriate resistant measure.
- D
- Incorrect because there is nothing wrong with reporting income as a dollar amount; the issue is the choice of the mean over the median as the summary statistic.