A regression of exam score on hours of sleep produces the equation y-hat = 40 + 5x with a 95% confidence interval for the slope of (2.8, 7.2). A student claims that this proves sleeping more hours causes higher exam scores. This claim is not justified because
- Athe confidence interval is too wide to draw any conclusions about the true population slope
- Bobservational data show association, not causation; lurking variables such as study habits may explain bothCorrect
- Cthe confidence interval does not contain zero, so the data establish that more sleep causes higher exam scores
- Dthe y-intercept of 40 is too high for the model to be valid
Why B is right
Regression analysis of observational data can establish a statistically significant association but cannot prove causation. Lurking variables (study habits, overall health, motivation, stress levels) may be associated with both sleep duration and exam performance. Without a randomized experiment controlling for confounders, the causal claim is not supported.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. The confidence interval (2.8, 7.2) does not contain zero, indicating a statistically significant positive relationship. Width alone does not invalidate conclusions about the population slope.
- C
- Incorrect. A significant positive slope demonstrates association, not causation. Statistical significance answers 'Is there a relationship?' not 'Does one variable cause the other?' It cannot establish that more sleep causes higher scores.
- D
- Incorrect. The y-intercept of 40 represents the predicted exam score for zero hours of sleep, which is an extrapolation. This does not invalidate the model within the data range or affect the causal argument.