A researcher is designing an experiment to test the effects of three types of background noise (silence, white noise, music) on reading comprehension. She has 45 participants. Which design feature would most reduce the impact of individual differences in reading ability on the results?
- AUsing only participants who read at the same speed
- BUsing a convenience sample from the local library
- CAssigning all fast readers to the silence condition and all slow readers to music
- DHaving each participant complete all three conditions in a random orderCorrect
Why D is right
Having each participant complete all three conditions (a repeated-measures or within-subjects design) eliminates individual differences as a source of variability between groups because each person serves as their own control. Randomizing the order prevents order effects from confounding the results.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because restricting to participants with the same reading speed severely limits the sample and reduces generalizability. A repeated-measures design is a more practical solution.
- B
- Incorrect because the sampling method (convenience vs. random) does not address within-experiment variability due to individual differences.
- C
- Incorrect because assigning fast readers to one condition and slow readers to another confounds reading ability with the treatment, which is exactly the problem to avoid.