In a data set with values 5, 8, 12, 15, 20, 24, 30, 35, 40, and 100, the value 100 is identified as a potential outlier. If 100 is removed from the data, which summary statistics change the most?
- AThe mean and standard deviation change the most.Correct
- BThe mean and IQR change the most.
- CThe median and standard deviation change the most.
- DThe median and IQR change the most.
Why A is right
The mean uses all values in its calculation and is pulled toward extreme values. Removing 100 would substantially decrease the mean. The standard deviation also uses all values and measures deviation from the mean; removing an extreme value decreases it significantly. The median and IQR are resistant measures and change little when an outlier is removed.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- The IQR is a resistant measure based on quartiles. Removing one extreme value would have minimal effect on Q1 and Q3, thus little effect on IQR.
- C
- While the SD is non-resistant, the median is resistant to outliers. The median would shift very little after removing 100.
- D
- The median and IQR are resistant to outliers. Removing a single extreme value causes minimal change in these measures.