Skip to content
AP Statistics · Exploring One-Variable Data and Collecting Data

Voluntary response

Voluntary response appears in 10 reviewed AP Statistics questions and sits in Exploring One-Variable Data and Collecting Data. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Voluntary response is tested

Example 1Medium
A high school has 2,000 students. The student council wants to estimate p, the proportion of all students at the school who support a later start time. Two data collection plans are proposed. Plan I: Select a simple random sample of 150 students from the school roster and ask each selected student the question. Plan II: Post the question on the school website and use the first 400 students who respond. The sample proportion p-hat from each plan will be used to estimate p. Which plan should the council use, and why?
  1. APlan I, because 400 is more than 10% of the 2,000 students, and that makes the p-hat from Plan II a biased estimator of p.
  2. BPlan I, because random selection makes p-hat an unbiased estimator of p; Plan II has less variability but is likely biased by voluntary response.Correct
  3. CNeither plan, because p-hat is an unbiased estimator of p only after the large counts condition is checked.
  4. DPlan II, because with 400 responses p-hat varies less from sample to sample, so it will be closer to p than Plan I.

Why B is right

p-hat is an unbiased estimator of p, meaning the center of its sampling distribution equals p, only when the data come from a random sample. Plan I meets that condition. Plan II is a voluntary response sample: students with strong opinions are more likely to respond, so its p-hat may be systematically too high or too low. Plan II's larger sample does lower the variability of p-hat, but a larger sample does not remove bias, so Plan I gives the better estimator.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Misuses the 10% condition. 400/2000 = 20% does break that condition, but the condition only controls whether the formula sqrt(p(1-p)/n) is accurate for the standard deviation. Sampling more than 10% does not make p-hat biased. Plan II's bias comes from voluntary response.
C
Mixes up the conditions: large counts (np >= 10 and n(1-p) >= 10) decides whether the sampling distribution is approximately normal. It has nothing to do with whether p-hat is unbiased, which depends on random sampling.
D
Mixes up variability with bias: a larger sample makes p-hat vary less, but a precise estimate from a biased method still centers on the wrong value, so being less variable does not mean it is closer to p.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Exploring One-Variable Data and Collecting Data.