Skip to content
AP U.S. History · Period 2: 1607-1754

Colonial society

Colonial society appears in 4 reviewed AP U.S. History questions and sits in Period 2: 1607-1754. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

The ranked social order of the colonies — gentry, middling farmers and artisans, servants, and enslaved people — held together by deference, and the strains that repeatedly cracked it, from Salem in 1692 to the revivals of the 1740s.

Why it matters

Deference was the organizing assumption: you obeyed your betters because they were your betters. Tracking where that assumption broke down explains both witchcraft panics and the anti-authority energy historians link forward to the Revolution.

How the exam tests it

Two angles recur. Salem items ask what broader tensions the trials expose, and the credited answer is plural — land disputes, gender, community boundaries, charter politics — never a single cause. Revival items ask how emotional conversion undercut deference to established authority.

Don’t confuse it with

Salem is not proof of unchallenged Puritan power; historians read it as a symptom of a community under strain after the 1684 charter revocation and the Dominion years.

Colonial society in real questions

Example 1Medium
"In the space of three months, the Reverend George Whitefield preached to more than 30,000 people across New England. Men and women wept openly at his words; hardened farmers fell to their knees in the fields. Church membership surged. Traditional ministers complained that he stirred up emotions without sound doctrine." — Modern historian describing the Great Awakening, c. 1740 The religious revivals described in this account most directly contributed to which of the following?
  1. AThe immediate political radicalization of colonists, producing organized demands for independence from Britain within a decade of the revivals' peak
  2. BA lasting decline in New England church attendance as established Congregationalist churches permanently lost their members to Whitefield's itinerant ministry
  3. CA broader cultural challenge to established hierarchies and deference to authority, as the emphasis on individual conversion democratized access to salvationCorrect
  4. DThe formal union of New England's Protestant denominations into a single established church capable of coordinating colonial missionary work more effectively

Why C is right

The Great Awakening (1730s-1740s) challenged established social hierarchies in multiple ways. By emphasizing that conversion was a personal, emotional experience available to all regardless of social status, education, or church membership, revivalists like Whitefield and Jonathan Edwards implicitly democratized spiritual authority. The itinerant preaching style itself was radical — bypassing parish boundaries and established ministerial credentials — and contributed to a broader cultural questioning of deference to traditional authorities that historians have connected to longer-term shifts toward Revolutionary-era egalitarianism.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because while the Great Awakening's cultural effects may have contributed to longer-term changes in colonial attitudes toward authority, the direct causal link to political radicalization within a decade is overstated; the political effects were indirect and developed over decades.
B
Incorrect because the revivals actually increased church membership and religious participation overall; while some traditional churches did lose members to New Light congregations, the net effect was a surge in religious engagement, not decline.
D
Incorrect because the Great Awakening actually increased denominational diversity and religious competition rather than unifying denominations; the revivals created new denominations (Baptists and Methodists grew significantly) and caused splits within existing churches between New Lights and Old Lights.
Example 2Harder
"The Salem witch trials of 1692: In a period of about eight months, over 150 people were accused of witchcraft, 19 were hanged, and one man was pressed to death with stones. The accusations began among young girls in Salem Village and spread rapidly through Essex County. Several historians have argued that the trials reflected social tensions, land disputes, and anxieties about Puritan identity in a changing Massachusetts." — Modern summary of the Salem witch trials A historian analyzing the Salem witch trials would most likely argue that they illustrate which of the following broader tensions in late seventeenth-century New England?
  1. AThe trials resulted primarily from the deliberate manipulation of the colony's legal and judicial system by a small group of elite ministers, magistrates, and wealthy landholders who sought to eliminate political rivals and consolidate their authority over the community
  2. BThe trials primarily demonstrate the dangers of religious extremism and should be understood as evidence that Puritan theology was uniquely prone to irrational violence when compared to other Protestant denominations of the period
  3. CThe trials show that colonial women used accusations of witchcraft as a deliberate political strategy to gain power and influence within Puritan communities that otherwise excluded them from public and civic life
  4. DThe trials reflect broader social anxieties in late seventeenth-century Massachusetts, including tensions over land, gender, community boundaries, and Puritan identity amid shifting political conditionsCorrect

Why D is right

Historians have interpreted the Salem witch trials as reflecting multiple intersecting social tensions: disputes between Salem Village and Salem Town over economic and political autonomy; anxieties about Massachusetts's changing political status after the revocation of the original charter (1684) and imposition of the Dominion of New England; gender tensions as accusations often targeted women who violated social norms; economic conflicts between more prosperous and less prosperous community members; and broader Puritan anxieties about maintaining community identity amid frontier violence, political uncertainty, and declining religious fervor. The trials cannot be reduced to a single cause.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because while minister Samuel Parris and local magistrates played important roles, reducing the trials to elite manipulation ignores the complex social dynamics involving many ordinary community members; the accusers themselves were not simply pawns of a conspiring elite.
B
Incorrect because characterizing Puritanism as 'uniquely prone to irrational violence' is an overgeneralization that ignores the specific historical context of 1692 and comparable episodes of witch-hunting in other Protestant and Catholic communities in the same period.
C
Incorrect because while gender dynamics were certainly present (many accusers were young women, and the accused were disproportionately women who challenged social norms), describing the accusations as a 'deliberate political strategy' for power overstates the accusers' agency and intent.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Period 2: 1607-1754.