The Dominion of New England, established by King James II in 1686, combined the New England colonies and later New York and New Jersey under a single royal governor, Edmund Andros, who ruled without legislative assemblies. Andros collected taxes without consent, revoked land titles, and suppressed town meetings. When the Glorious Revolution removed James II in 1688, colonists rose up, arrested Andros, and restored their former charters.
Which of the following most directly led to the situation described in this passage?
- AJames II's mercantilist agenda, which required consolidating colonial administration to more efficiently collect customs revenues and enforce the Navigation ActsCorrect
- BThe formal request of New England colonial leaders, who voluntarily dissolved their charters and invited direct royal governance to resolve intercolonial disputes
- CColonial assemblies' mismanagement of local finances, which prompted the Crown to impose direct royal governance to restore fiscal order in New England
- DGrowing Spanish and French military threats to the New England coast, which convinced James II that consolidated royal authority was necessary for colonial defense
Why A is right
James II's creation of the Dominion of New England was part of his broader effort to rationalize and centralize the English colonial empire for more effective mercantilist administration. The Navigation Acts were being widely evaded by New England merchants, and multiple separate colonial governments made enforcement difficult. The Dominion was designed to bring New England firmly under royal administrative control, eliminating the legislative assemblies that had developed significant autonomy.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because New England colonial leaders vigorously opposed the revocation of their charters and the Dominion's imposition; they did not voluntarily invite direct royal governance and were relieved when the Glorious Revolution enabled them to restore their charters.
- C
- Incorrect because colonial assemblies had not mismanaged finances in a way that prompted royal intervention; the Crown's motivation was to increase central control and customs collection, not to fix fiscal problems that colonial governments had created.
- D
- Incorrect because while colonial defense was used as a justification for the Dominion (consolidation would theoretically improve military coordination), the primary motivation was mercantilist administration and control, not genuine military emergency.