"The tobacco economy of seventeenth-century Virginia was built on a labor-intensive monoculture that required large numbers of workers but generated returns sufficient only in years of high prices. When tobacco prices fell, planters faced ruin unless they could reduce labor costs. Indentured servants — whose contracts typically ran four to seven years — expected land and tools upon completion; enslaved people could be worked for life without the prospect of freedom and land-hunger." — Chesapeake economic history, 2010
Which of the following most directly contributed to the perspective expressed in this passage?
- AFalling tobacco prices coincided with growing numbers of landless former servants demanding land and with a declining cost of enslaved Africans relative to indentured servants, making racial slavery economically attractive to plantersCorrect
- BEnglish workers grew increasingly reluctant to sign indenture contracts as knowledge of Virginia's harsh conditions and high mortality spread in England, drying up the supply of servants on which the tobacco economy had long depended
- CVirginia colonial law prohibited the continued use of indentured servants after 1680, forcing planters across the tidewater to abandon contract labor and shift entirely to a permanent enslaved workforce
- DEnglish Quaker pressure on Virginia planters to abolish indentured servitude because of its similarities to slavery led planters to adopt racial slavery as a legally distinct and therefore acceptable alternative
Why A is right
The shift from indentured to enslaved labor in the Chesapeake was driven by multiple converging factors: as Atlantic trade expanded, the supply of enslaved Africans increased and their relative cost fell; former servants who had completed their contracts demanded land that was no longer available on the tidewater; and Bacon's Rebellion (1676) alarmed planters about the danger of a large population of landless, discontented former servants. Enslaved people offered a permanent, hereditary labor force without the dangerous political expectations of freed servants.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the declining supply of English servants was a real trend, but the passage asks about the economic attractiveness of slavery to planters, not the supply of servants; the decisive factor was the economic calculation favoring permanent enslaved labor.
- C
- Incorrect because Virginia colonial law did not prohibit indentured servants after 1680; the shift was economically driven, not legally mandated, and indentured servitude continued to exist while declining as slavery became more advantageous.
- D
- Incorrect because Quaker abolitionist pressure on Virginia planters was minimal and had no significant legislative effect in the seventeenth century; the shift to slavery was driven by economic factors, not Quaker advocacy.