Roger Williams held that the civil magistrate had no right to punish violations of the first four commandments, which deal with humanity's relationship to God. He further argued that the king had no right to grant lands in America because the land belonged to the indigenous inhabitants, not to the English Crown. For these views, the Massachusetts Bay Court ordered him banished in 1636.
The argument described in this passage most closely reflects which of the following historical developments?
- AA gradual moderation of Puritan theology in Massachusetts Bay that brought the colony's leadership toward Williams's positions by mid-century
- BThe influence of European Enlightenment philosophy on colonial religious thought, which led Williams to reject Calvinism in favor of rational deism
- CThe emergence of principled arguments for separation of church and state and for indigenous land rights that challenged Massachusetts Bay's dominant ideologyCorrect
- DA quiet majority view among Puritan clergy who privately shared Williams's theology but feared the consequences of voicing such dissent openly
Why C is right
Roger Williams's positions were remarkable precisely because they challenged the dominant assumptions of Puritan Massachusetts: that civil government should enforce religious conformity (positions 1-4 of the Ten Commandments) and that English royal charters legitimately granted indigenous lands. His banishment illustrates how threatening these ideas were to Massachusetts Bay's theocratic framework, yet they foreshadowed later American traditions of church-state separation and indigenous land rights.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Puritan Massachusetts did not gradually moderate toward Williams's positions; the colony maintained its theocratic structure and continued to persecute religious dissenters through the seventeenth century.
- B
- Incorrect because Williams's positions were derived from his reading of Scripture and Separatist theology, not from Enlightenment philosophy; the European Enlightenment had not yet significantly influenced colonial thought in the 1630s, and Williams was a Calvinist, not a deist.
- D
- Incorrect because Williams's positions were minority views that the Puritan establishment actively suppressed; they were not widely shared by the clergy who supported magistrates' enforcement of religious conformity.