"William Penn's Frame of Government for Pennsylvania, 1682: The Governor and freemen of this province shall meet once a year to make laws... No person who shall confess and acknowledge one almighty God shall be molested in his person or estate because of his conscientious persuasion or practice."
— William Penn, Frame of Government, 1682
Pennsylvania's colonial government as described in this document most directly reflected which of the following?
- AQuaker beliefs in the Inner Light and the spiritual equality of all people before God, which fostered broad religious toleration and relatively peaceful dealings with indigenous peoplesCorrect
- BThe English crown's deliberate policy of establishing model colonies meant to show the superiority of religious toleration over the theocratic governments of Puritan New England
- CThe Dutch commercial tradition of religious toleration that Penn was thought to have absorbed during his travels in the Netherlands and then written into his Pennsylvania proprietary charter
- DA purely pragmatic commercial calculation by Penn to attract the largest possible number of settlers by offering religious freedom as a recruitment incentive for immigration
Why A is right
Penn's Frame of Government reflected Quaker theology, which emphasized the 'Inner Light' — the belief that God's spirit directly illuminated every person's conscience, making external religious coercion both unnecessary and harmful. Quakers' experience of persecution in England made them committed advocates for religious toleration. Penn also conducted unusually fair dealings with the Lenape (Delaware) people, purchasing land through direct negotiation rather than conquest, reflecting Quaker principles of peace and equality. Pennsylvania became one of the most religiously diverse and tolerant of the English colonies.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the English crown did not have a deliberate policy of establishing model tolerant colonies; indeed, the crown established the Anglican Church in several colonies and was not ideologically committed to religious toleration as a colonial policy.
- C
- Incorrect because while Penn did travel to Germany and the Netherlands recruiting colonists, his commitment to religious toleration was rooted primarily in Quaker theology rather than Dutch commercial practice; Penn was a devout Quaker whose beliefs drove his colonial policies.
- D
- Incorrect because while Pennsylvania's toleration did attract diverse settlers and was practically advantageous, reducing Penn's motivation to pure pragmatism ignores the documented centrality of Quaker religious conviction in his public statements and actions.